1959-1960 ALL-AMERICAN TEAMS
| East | |
| Tom Wahman - Dartmouth | GOALIE |
| Tom "Red" Martin - Boston College | DEFENSE |
| Rusty Ingersoll - Dartmouth | DEFENSE |
| Terry Slater - St. Lawrence University | FORWARD |
| Phil Latreille - Middlebury | FORWARD |
| Art Chisholm - Northeastern | FORWARD |
| West | |
| George Cuculick - Michigan Tech | GOALIE |
| Marty Howe - Denver University | DEFENSE |
| George Konik - Denver University | DEFENSE |
| Paul Coppo - Michigan Tech | FORWARD |
| Reg Morelli - North Dakota | FORWARD |
| Bill Masterton - Denver University | FORWARD |
