1957-1958 ALL-AMERICAN TEAMS
| East | |
| Eddie Macdonald - Clarkson | GOALIE |
| Bob Dupuis - Boston University | DEFENSE |
| Don MacLeod - Boston University | DEFENSE |
| Bob Cleary - Harvard University | FORWARD |
| Bob Marquis - Boston University | FORWARD |
| Paul Midghall - Rensselaer | FORWARD |
| West | |
| Jack McCartan - Minnesota | GOALIE |
| Bill Steenson - North Dakota | DEFENSE |
| Ed Zemrau - Denver University | DEFENSE |
| Dick Burg - Minnesota | FORWARD |
| Red Hay - Colorado College | FORWARD |
| Bob McCusker - Colorado College | FORWARD |
| Bob White - Michigan | FORWARD |
