1999-2000 MEN'S UNIVERSITY DIVISION ALL-AMERICANS
| First Team East | |
| Joel Laing, Rensselaer, SR (Maryfield, SASK) |
GOALIE |
| Justin Harney, St. Lawrence, SR (Hopkinton, MA) |
DEFENSE |
| Mike Mottau, Boston College, SR@* (Avon, MA) |
DEFENSE |
| Brian Gionta, Boston College, JR@* (Rochester, NY) |
FORWARD |
| Andy McDonald, Colgate, SR (Strathroy, ONT) |
FORWARD |
| Jeff Farkas, Boston College, SR (Williamsville, NY) |
FORWARD |
| First Team West | |
| Karl Goehring, North Dakota, JR (AppleValley, MN) |
GOALIE |
| Jeff Dessner, Wisconsin, JR (Glenview, IL) |
DEFENSE |
| Jeff Jillson, Michigan, SO (North Smithfield, RI) |
DEFENSE |
| Shawn Horcoff, Michigan State, SR (Castlegar, BC) |
FORWARD |
| Jeff Panzer, North Dakota, JR (Grand Forks, ND) |
FORWARD |
| Steve Reinprecht, Wisconsin, SR (Edmonton, ALTA) |
FORWARD |
| Second Team East | |
| Ty Conklin, New Hampshire, JR (Anchorage, AK) |
GOALIE |
| Chris Dyment, Boston University, SO (Reading, MA) |
DEFENSE |
| Brian Pothier, Rensselaer, SR (New Bedford, MA) |
FORWARD |
| Brandon Dietrich, St. Lawrence, SO (Waterloo, ONT) |
DEFENSE |
| Cory Larose, Maine, SR (Campbellton, NB) |
FORWARD |
| Brad Tapper, Rensselaer, JR (Scarborough, ONT) |
FORWARD |
| Second Team West | |
| Jayme Platt, Lake Superior, JR (Redmond, WA) |
GOALIE |
| Mike Pudlick, St. Cloud, SO (Blaine, MN) |
DEFENSE |
| Mike Weaver, Michigan State, SR# (Bramalea, ONT) |
FORWARD |
| Mike Comrie, Michigan, SO (Edmonton, ALTA) |
DEFENSE |
| Lee Goren, North Dakota, SR (Winnipeg, MAN) |
FORWARD |
| Dany Heatley, Wisconsin, FR (Calgary, ALTA) |
FORWARD |
| * First Team in 1998-99 @Second Team in 1997-98 # Second team in 1998-99 |
|
1999-2000 MEN'S COLLEGE DIVISION ALL-AMERICANS
| First Team East | |
| David Haimson, Williams, SR | GOALIE |
| Ben Barnett, Middlebury, SR | DEFENSE |
| Mike Ludwar, Norwich, SR | DEFENSE |
| Keith Aucoin, Norwich, JR | FORWARD |
| Mark Bellemare, Norwich, SR | FORWARD |
| Curt Goldman, Middlebury, SR | FORWARD |
| First Team West | |
| Brian Howard, Concordia, JR | GOALIE |
| Tommy Cianflone, St. Norbert, SR | DEFENSE |
| Rob Gramer, Concordia, SR | DEFENSE |
| Steve Aronson, St. Thomas, SR | FORWARD |
| Ryan Maxson, UW-Stevens Point, JR | FORWARD |
| Kevin Adam, Bethel, SR | FORWARD |
| Second Team East | |
| Lou Mastromarino, Salem State, SR | GOALIE |
| Brian Collum, Southern Maine, SR | DEFENSE |
| Bryan Murray, Plattsburgh, JR | DEFENSE |
| John Giannacopoulos, Middlebury, SR | FORWARD |
| Jeff Paluseo, Plattsburgh, SR | FORWARD |
| Pat Staerker, RIT, SR | FORWARD |
| Second Team West | |
| Bobby Gould, UW-Stevens Point, SO | GOALIE |
| Jared Gustafson, Bethel, JR | DEFENSE |
| Mike McMahon, St. Thomas, JR | DEFENSE |
| Brian Bolf, St. Thomas, SR | FORWARD |
| Jeff Glowa, UW-Superior, JR | FORWARD |
| Adam Sedgwick, St. Norbert, JR | FORWARD |
1999-2000 American Women's College Hockey Alliance Division I All-Americans
| Player | School | Class | Position | Hometown |
| Sara DeCosta | Providence | JR | Goalie | Warwick, RI |
| Tara Mounsey | Brown | JR | Defense | Concord, NH |
| Angela Ruggerio | Harvard | SO | Defense | Grosse Pointe Woods, MI |
| Jennifer Botterill | Harvard | SO | Forward | Winnipeg, MAN |
| Jenny Schmidgall | Minnesota-Duluth | SO | Forward | Edina, MN |
| Carisa Zaban | New Hampshire | SR | Forward | Glenview, IL |
1999-2000 American Women's College Hockey Alliance Division III All-Americans
| Player | School | Class | Position | Hometown |
| Josie Chapman | Colby | JR | Goalie | Bristol, RI |
| Catherine Elkins | Middlebury | SO | Defense | Bernardsville, NJ |
| Catherine Pullins | Middlebury | SR | Defense | New Canaan, CT |
| Michelle Labbe | Middlebury | JR | Forward | Pte. Claire, QUE |
| Heather Murphy | Colgate | SO | Forward | St. Paul, MN |
| Angie Rieger | Augsburg | JR | Forward | Courtland, MN |
| Sylvia Ryan | Middlebury | SR | Forward | Stellarton, NS |
