1958-1959 ALL-AMERICAN TEAMS
| East | |
| Gerry Jones - Yale University | GOALIE |
| Joe Jangro - Boston College | DEFENSE |
| Pat Presley - St. Lawrence University | DEFENSE |
| Bob Marquis - Boston University | FORWARD |
| Paul Midghall - Rensselaer | FORWARD |
| Phil Latreille - Middlebury | FORWARD |
| West | |
| Joe Selinger - Michigan State | GOALIE |
| Bill Steenson - North Dakota | DEFENSE |
| Bob Watt - Michigan | DEFENSE |
| John Kosiancic - Michigan Tech | FORWARD |
| Bob White - Michigan | FORWARD |
| Murray Williamson - Minnesota | FORWARD |
